We just so happened to have the Wilton treat bags and they were a perfect fit! I mean PERFECT! Label from Wilton bags shown below.
We then went here to What Katie Scrapped and found the cute little freebie bag tags and actually emailed her for blank ones so that we could add our own personalized text. And what do you know she already had them! We just re sized them to 3" wide to fit our bags.
So fun! The kids love them. I hear the star is the best because when one point wares down you have 4 more. Hehe!